It takes 39 minutes to actually get to the story of Part 2. I thought the first one had too many flashbacks, but this is ridiculous. The majority of this film is told through a narrated series of memories being told to a psychologist. The main character this time is the little brother of last episode's protagonist. So the extended re-telling of the original murder of the boy Billy's parents from the first film is now told by the little baby in the scene, Ricky. This is almost as believable as that flashback in The Hills Have Eyes Part 2 that is from the family's dog.
I should have known better during the opening credits of this movie. Any time that there are no less that eight names in the "written by" credits, you can be pretty sure you are in for a big pile of excrement.
The only movies to successfully re-tell the original in the sequels was the Evil Dead series. And the key to Evil Dead 2: Dead By Dawn was to completely re-shoot the pre-story to help blend the backstory into the new movie to get viewers that missed the original up to date without insulting your audience that is returning. Silent Night 2 is more along the lines of a filler episode of a television series that uses clips to fill in their season when they are out of original material.
So after we sit through about 80% of the original film, we can finally get to the new story of Part 2. What would a bunch of nuns operating an orphanage do to deal with the little brother of a guy who dressed up as Santa and punished people to death? Make sure he is adopted by a nice Jewish family, of course. No Christmas rage triggers here. Only problem is that now anytime he sees nuns or the color red he freaks out.
The real problem here is that once we finally get to the story of 12 year old Ricky, we really don't care anymore. Then things get confusing when the kid in the 17 year old flashbacks is not the same guy that plays 18 year old Ricky in his most recent flashbacks (who is also playing Ricky in the present day). It really starts to feel like the filmmakers just filmed chunks of the movie whenever they had a chance and tried to tie it all up together in post-production.
The following killing rampage doesn't bother to follow any of the rules previously established in the movies. We no longer need a Santa, Christmas or even the color red to trigger Ricky to punish people. Now he just kills because he can. This scene is so classy that the highlight is Ricky shooting a guy taking out the trash and screaming "GARBAGE DAY". Its in one of the trailers. Actually this entire sequence makes up most of the trailer on the extras.So we have gotten so far off topic by now in the movie that the only thing I am thinking about it is, "how many bullets can he possibly have in that handgun?" I will admit that the way the film answers that question is one of the only clever moments it has.
So the ending that you expected from the start of the movie finally happens. We finally get to see Ricky dressed up as Santa, but the actor is hamming it up so much by now that he comes off as a cross between Jack from The Shining and Freddy Kruger. Meanwhile the end of the movie plays off like an extended rip off of the opening from Friday the 13th Part 2. Nothing new here.
But wait...I forgot to mention that they use EVEN MORE footage from the original when Ricky takes his girlfriend to the movies to see a killer Santa film. Now this is just getting stupid!
There is nothing subtle or remotely interesting about this cheese ball sequel. While the original had a kind of sleazy charm, this one failed to keep me entertained. I am glad that I picked up this Christmas Survival Double Feature DVD set so that I could re-live the original, now I know why I couldn't remember anything about Part 2. There really wasn't enough new material to stand out in my mind. Oh, and it's also sad that there are much more Special Features on the disc for Part 2 than the original.
I would only recommend this movie to people that haven't seen the original film yet, but to be honest, you're probably better off just waiting till you can get your hands on Part 1.





