When Halloween II hit theaters I was worried again. The original Halloween II is not a great movie. It is an ok sequel, but at the same time an obvious cash in on the previous success. It was a rush job and Carpenter didn't want to have anything to do with it. So why should we remake a movie that wasn't great in the first place? Or maybe I'm wrong...maybe that is the perfect reason to remake a film. Maybe its a second chance to make a better story. But the movie I saw in the theater was not an improvement. It was a confusing, disjointed mess that could not tell me a clear story. While I appreciated the first half hour being a reference to the original part 2, what followed didn't make any sense.
So I think that brings us up to date. A while back I picked up a used copy of the "unrated, director's cut" and decided to give the movie a second try. I am definitely glad that I did. This time around the dream-like sequences of what Michael sees were more integrated with the plot and made more sense. You also really get a clear picture of how heartless Dr. Loomis becomes as he completely sells his soul for the money from his true crime books. I also love that (spoiler) this is the first time Michael Myers is aloud to stalk and kill without his mask. This shows us that his real face has become his mask and it is just as scary. And as usual, I really appreciate what Zombie is able to do with sound design to add emotion to the aftermath of destruction. You almost want to cry for characters that have to find their loved one's brutalized remains. The film is definitely intense and gruesome and makes the viewer involuntarily cringe from the physical violence.
I do still have one big issue with the film and it is with the evolution of the character of Lorie Strode. In the first film she is a pretty typical teenager, maybe a little tougher than her friends but still the girl next door. Now she has become a punk rock rebel who curses out her therapist and works in a super hip record store/coffee shop. Her bedroom is a shrine to cool and the centerpiece is a massive poster of Charles Manson over her bed. I have a hard time believing that a survivor of a serial killer's rampage would adorn her room with the image of one of the most notorious serial killers in history. I really think in his quest to make Lorie his ultimate teenager that Rob dropped the ball here.
Bottom line - I recommend the director's cut (not theatrical) to fans of horror, slashers, the Halloween franchise and Rob Zombie - but only if you've seen part one.